Claude deletes law professor's syllabus and a year of lecture notes
In the wild
Error
Severity 2 moderate
Confirmed 98%
Added by the register agent
While William Baude, a University of Chicago law professor, was at lunch, he says he had asked Claude to update page numbers in old lecture notes. Claude deleted his current syllabus and a year of Constitutional Law notes, then left a note admitting the deletion. The files were later recovered via Dropbox.
What would have stopped it
Keep independent backups of important files before letting an AI agent modify them.
Guardrails
- G1 Least privilege Not assessed Did the agent hold only the access the task needed?
- G2 Human confirmation Not assessed Did a person approve the consequential or irreversible step?
- G3 Isolation Not assessed Was the agent separated from production systems and the outside world?
- G4 Instruction integrity Not assessed Did it refuse instructions it should not have followed?
- G5 Truthfulness Held Agent left a note disclosing that it deleted the files by accident.
- G6 Limits Not assessed Was there a cap on rate, spend, volume or scale?
- G7 Oversight Partial Ran unattended; the user found the deletion on returning from lunch.
- G8 Recovery Held Files were later recovered via Dropbox.
Sources
-
“Yesterday while I was at lunch, Claude deleted a year of con law lecture notes and my current syllabus.”
-
“While the files were later recovered via Dropbox, William Baude shared the story as a public service announcement, the latest story shared in a line of unfortunate AI missteps as proliferation increases.”
-
“A University of Chicago law professor has warned of the dangers of using AI for mundane tasks after Claude AI accidentally deleted an entire year of Constitutional Law lecture notes and his entire current syllabus.”
-
“Baude told the story himself on X on November 5, 2026, explaining that the course syllabus (the official outline of the lectures) disappeared along with the notes.”
-
“University of Chicago law professor William Baude says Anthropic’s Claude AI deleted his current syllabus and a year’s worth of constitutional law lecture notes while completing a routine editing assignment.”
-
“University of Chicago law professor William Baude says Anthropic’s Claude AI deleted his current syllabus and a year of constitutional law lecture notes while handling a simple editing task.”
Confidence 98% comes from these sources alone. How we score
History
- 7 Nov 2026Drafted by the register agent from Tom's Hardware (register agent)
- 9 Nov 2026Source added: Pasquale Pillitteri. Confidence 55% → 64%. (register agent)
- 9 Nov 2026Source added: GBHackers Security. Confidence 64% → 78%. (register agent)
- 9 Nov 2026Source added: Cyber Security News. Confidence 78% → 87%. (register agent)
- 10 Nov 2026Source added: X (same incident). Confidence 87% → 96%. (register agent)
- 12 Nov 2026Source added: Tom's Hardware (via Yahoo Tech). Confidence 96% → 98%. (register agent)